How to move class method out of gui modul

California

Hello, this is my first post here. Very small and simple working example of GUI with radiobutton is posted to describe the situation. It contains two modules: "main.py" and "gui.py" (made by QTCreator). Module "gui.py" contains methos "print_situation", which is called from main module. I would like to moove this method into third module called "apps.py" in to class "my_app" and I would still like to call it from main module, from the same place.
I don't know if this is even possible, becouse searching over net didn't find any example like this one.
So, the question is: how to do it? This solution would simplify my large project.

Regards, Vlado

main.py

# python 2.7.9

from PyQt4 import QtCore, QtGui
from gui import Ui_Form
import sys


if __name__ == "__main__":

    app = QtGui.QApplication(sys.argv)

    gui_master = QtGui.QWidget()
    master = Ui_Form()
    master.setupUi(gui_master)

    master.radioButton.clicked.connect(master.print_situation)

    gui_master.show()
    sys.exit(app.exec_())

gui.py

from PyQt4 import QtCore, QtGui

try:
    _fromUtf8 = QtCore.QString.fromUtf8
except AttributeError:
    def _fromUtf8(s):
        return s

try:
    _encoding = QtGui.QApplication.UnicodeUTF8
    def _translate(context, text, disambig):
        return QtGui.QApplication.translate(context, text, disambig, _encoding)
except AttributeError:
    def _translate(context, text, disambig):
        return QtGui.QApplication.translate(context, text, disambig)

class Ui_Form(object):
    def setupUi(self, Form):
        Form.setObjectName(_fromUtf8("Form"))
        Form.resize(300, 150)
        self.radioButton = QtGui.QRadioButton(Form)
        self.radioButton.setGeometry(QtCore.QRect(100, 75, 118, 26))
        self.radioButton.setObjectName(_fromUtf8("radioButton"))

        self.retranslateUi(Form)
        QtCore.QMetaObject.connectSlotsByName(Form)

    def retranslateUi(self, Form):
        Form.setWindowTitle(_translate("Form", "Form", None))
        self.radioButton.setText(_translate("Form", "RadioButton", None))

    def print_situation(self):
        if self.radioButton.isChecked():
            print "Checked"
        else:
            print "Unchecked"


if __name__ == "__main__":
    import sys
    app = QtGui.QApplication(sys.argv)
    Form = QtGui.QWidget()
    ui = Ui_Form()
    ui.setupUi(Form)
    Form.show()
    sys.exit(app.exec_())

SGaist

HI and welcome to devnet,

You can't move a class method out of a class in python.

What exactly are you trying to accomplish ?

California

Hi and thanks for your reply. In my project code "gui.py" module takes already more than 800 lines of code and and it's not even finished. I would like to keep this module as small as possible. But if you say mooving methods like "print_situation" out of the class "Ui_Form" is impossible then there is nothing I can do.
My project involves Raspberry Pi as a Masteri in RS485 network with several slaves for meassuring temperatures, air preassure, consumption of electric energy, ...
Everything Works ok so far, but it's not finished yet. I Will post some pictures later this day
I intend to add some diagrams into project, what tool or librarry would you suggest to do that?

Regards, Vlado

jsulm

@California Depending on what this print_situation does you can move its content to a function/method in apps.py and call it from print_situation

mrjj

Hi
Disclaimer: Python noob :)

Since Python do not seem to have any concept of Private, there should be nothing wrong with
some function are in other file or object. You just have to give parameter so it can access what it needs

def print_situation(self):
if self.radioButton.isChecked():
print "Checked"
else:
print "Unchecked"

So I assume if you call it from main
otherclass.print_situation(gui_master)

and it would still work. as the Self then would have radioButton.
Or might need you define the object/function like
class OtherClass(object):
def myPrint(self, Form):

To allow myPrint to talk to Forms widgets.

This have one big disadvantages though. You will bleed details to the other modules in terms it knows what controls the form has etc.

For a better design, you can use signals
Just define some new Signals in the main Form for the data that needs to flow there.
The classes in apps.py" then just have the slots and you hook it all up
in main.

So in main you would just
emit Print( data_for_print )

and some class in apps would do the real work.

California

@jsulm name of the method "print_situation" is just for testing. Real method looks like this one below.

    def read_190_allowed(self):
        if self.radioButton.isChecked():
            read_flag == 1
        else:
            read_flag == 0
        return read_flag

@mrjj forgive me, I am fighting with python for last six months, so my knowledge is very limitted so far ...
I did not use signals yet, but this is the chance to do it.
Some test code with third module including error message will be posted here later.

Ragards Vlado

jsulm

@California I don't see what's the point to move these 5 lines of code to another location.

SGaist

Depending on how "the file is getting too big", you may have an architecture problem. Proper encapsulation is as important in python than it is in C++.

California

@jsulm If there would only this method it wouldn't be a problem at all, but with a lot of them ...
Complete module will be posted here, maybe there is another way to do the same thing ...

California

Ok, module "gui.py" is posted below. Also imidge of the front page of my GUI.
I had to delete code made by QTCreator (to much characters ...)

# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-

# Form implementation generated from reading ui file 'Master_26b.ui'
#
# Created: Mon Jan  9 16:23:54 2017
#      by: PyQt4 UI code generator 4.11.2
#
# WARNING! All changes made in this file will be lost!

from PyQt4 import QtCore, QtGui
import PyQt4.Qwt5 as Qwt
from slave_160 import(convert_byte_to_bin_out, convert_long_to_bytes,
    convert_float_to_MICROCHIP_32bit, convert_MICROCHIP_32bit_to_float,
    crc_calc, set_temp, read_temp)
from slave_190a import(read_time, set_time, check_heating, control_heating,
    control_heating_5_6, set_time_zg, set_time_sp)
from slave_220 import(convert_MICROCHIP_32bit_to_float, crc_calc,
     read_hladilnica, convert_byte_to_bin_out_2, set_hladilnica,
      convert_float_to_MICROCHIP_32bit, convert_long_to_bytes)
from PyQt4.QtCore import *
from PyQt4.QtGui import *

try:
    _fromUtf8 = QtCore.QString.fromUtf8
except AttributeError:
    def _fromUtf8(s):
        return s

try:
    _encoding = QtGui.QApplication.UnicodeUTF8
    def _translate(context, text, disambig):
        return QtGui.QApplication.translate(context, text, disambig, _encoding)
except AttributeError:
    def _translate(context, text, disambig):
        return QtGui.QApplication.translate(context, text, disambig)


class Ui_Izbira(QtGui.QWidget):  # class Ui_Izbira(object):  DELA ENAKO V OBEH PRIMERIH
    def setupUi(self, Izbira):
        Izbira.setObjectName(_fromUtf8("Izbira"))
        Izbira.resize(908, 619)

        Izbira.setStyleSheet(_fromUtf8("background-color: rgb(200, 200, 200);"))
        self.col = QtGui.QColor(0, 0, 0)

    ...

    def set_time_zgoraj(self, arg):
        time_zg = int(self.lineEdit_Up_day.text())
        set_time_zg(time_zg)

    def set_time_spodaj(self, arg):
        time_sp = (int(self.lineEdit_Down_day.text()) + 10)
        set_time_sp(time_sp)

    def vklop_izklop_ogrevanje(self):
        if self.Ogrevanje_izven_sezone.checkState() == QtCore.Qt.Checked:
            komanda = 241
        else:
            komanda = 31

        ogrevanje = control_heating(komanda)

        if ogrevanje == 74:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0

        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Ogrevanje_sezona_aktivno.setStyleSheet(
            "QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

    def read_190_allowed(self):
        if self.checkBox_Read_190.checkState() == QtCore.Qt.Checked:
            read_190_flag = 1
        else:
            read_190_flag = 0
        return read_190_flag

    def up_5_6_OnOff(self):
        if self.checkBox_Up_5_6.checkState() == QtCore.Qt.Checked:
            up_5_6 = 27
        else:
            up_5_6 = 26
        ogrevanje_5_6 = control_heating_5_6(up_5_6)

        if ogrevanje_5_6 == 27:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0

        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Ogrevanje_zgoraj_5_6.setStyleSheet(
            "QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

    def set_time_190(self, arg, ):
        num_year = int(self.lineEdit_Year.text())
        num_month = int(self.lineEdit_Month.text())
        num_day = int(self.lineEdit_Day.text())
        num_hour = int(self.lineEdit_Hour.text())
        num_min = int(self.lineEdit_Minutte.text())
        num_sec = int(self.lineEdit_Seconds.text())
        num_wekday = int(self.lineEdit_WeekDay_SET.text())
        num_up56 = 26
        num_up = int(self.lineEdit_Up_day.text())
        num_down = int(self.lineEdit_Down_day.text()) + 10
        set_time(num_year, num_month, num_day, num_hour,
            num_min, num_sec, num_wekday, num_up56, num_up, num_down)

    def read_slave_190(self):
        timecomplete = read_time()
        self.lineEdit_Year.setText(str("%.0f" % timecomplete[0]))
        self.lineEdit_Month.setText(str("%.0f" % timecomplete[1]))
        self.lineEdit_Day.setText(str("%.0f" % timecomplete[2]))
        self.lineEdit_Hour.setText(str("%.0f" % timecomplete[3]))
        self.lineEdit_Minutte.setText(str("%.0f" % timecomplete[4]))
        self.lineEdit_Seconds.setText(str("%.0f" % timecomplete[5]))
        self.lineEdit_WeekDay_SET.setText(str("%.0f" % timecomplete[6]))

        if timecomplete[6] == 1:
            self.lineEdit_WeekDay.setText("Ponedeljek")
        elif timecomplete[6] == 2:
            self.lineEdit_WeekDay.setText("Torek")
        elif timecomplete[6] == 3:
            self.lineEdit_WeekDay.setText("Sreda")
        elif timecomplete[6] == 4:
            self.lineEdit_WeekDay.setText("Cetrtek")
        elif timecomplete[6] == 5:
            self.lineEdit_WeekDay.setText("Petek")
        elif timecomplete[6] == 6:
            self.lineEdit_WeekDay.setText("Sobota")
        elif timecomplete[6] == 7:
            self.lineEdit_WeekDay.setText("Nedelja")
        self.lineEdit_Up_day.setText(str("%.0f" % timecomplete[8]))
        self.lineEdit_Down_day.setText(str("%.0f" % (timecomplete[9] - 10)))
        ogrevanje = check_heating()
        if ogrevanje == 74:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0
        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Ogrevanje_sezona_aktivno.setStyleSheet(
            "QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

    def read_slave_220(self):
        hladilnica = read_hladilnica()
        self.lineEdit_Hladilnica_Temperatura.setText(str("%.2f" % hladilnica[0]))
        self.lineEdit_Hladilnica_Vlaga.setText(str("%.2f" % hladilnica[1]))
        self.lineEdit_Hladilnica_set_temp.setText(str("%.0f" % hladilnica[2]))
        #self.lineEdit_Hladilnica_set_temp.setText(str("%.1f" % (float(hladilnica[2] / 10))))
        self.lineEdit_Hladilnica_set_vlaga.setText(str("%.0f" % hladilnica[3]))
        a = convert_byte_to_bin_out_2(hladilnica[4])
        if a[0] == 1:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0
        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Hladilnica_kompresor_aktivno.setStyleSheet("QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())
        if a[1] == 1:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0
        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Hladilnic_vlazilec_aktivno.setStyleSheet("QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())
        if a[1] == 1:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0
        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Hladilnica_ventilator_aktivno.setStyleSheet("QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

    def set_slave_220(self, arg):
        num_ht = int(self.lineEdit_Hladilnica_set_temp.text())
        #num_ht = int(float(self.lineEdit_Hladilnica_set_temp.text()))
        num_hv = int(self.lineEdit_Hladilnica_set_vlaga.text())
        set_hladilnica(7.5, 75, num_ht, num_hv, 0)

    def set_slave_160(self, arg):
        num_zg = float(self.lineEdit_SZgoraj.text())
        num_sp = float(self.lineEdit_SSpodaj.text())
        set_temp(num_zg, num_sp)

    def read_slave_160(self):
        temp = read_temp()
        self.lineEdit_ZG.setText(str("%.2f" % temp[0]))
        self.lineEdit_SP.setText(str("%.2f" % temp[1]))
        self.lineEdit_BO.setText(str("%.2f" % temp[2]))
        self.lineEdit_SO.setText(str("%.2f" % temp[3]))
        self.lineEdit_PE.setText(str("%.2f" % temp[4]))
        self.lineEdit_ZU.setText(str("%.2f" % temp[5]))
        self.lineEdit_SZgoraj.setText(str("%.2f" % temp[6]))
        self.lineEdit_SSpodaj.setText(str("%.2f" % temp[7]))
        a = convert_byte_to_bin_out(temp[8])

        if a[0] == 1:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0

        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Pec_aktivno.setStyleSheet("QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

        if a[1] == 1:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0

        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Sonce_aktivno.setStyleSheet("QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

        if a[2] == 1:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0

        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Bojler_aktivno.setStyleSheet("QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

        if a[3] == 1:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0

        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Spodaj_aktivno.setStyleSheet("QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

        if a[4] == 1:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0

        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Zgoraj_aktivno.setStyleSheet("QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

        if a[5] == 1:
            val = 255
        else:
            val = 0

        self.col.setGreen(val)
        self.Crpalka_aktivno.setStyleSheet("QFrame { background-color: %s }" %
            self.col.name())

#from qwt_plot import QwtPlot

if __name__ == "__main__":
    import sys
    app = QtGui.QApplication(sys.argv)
    Izbira = QtGui.QTabWidget()
    ui = Ui_Izbira()
    ui.setupUi(Izbira)
    Izbira.show()
    sys.exit(app.exec_())

slave 190
alt text

California

Picture of GUI is missing ...
alt text

California

Ok, this time succesed.
alt text

SGaist

Just a quick note, you do realise that you are modifying a file which clearly states in its header that it can be regenerated and all your modification lost ?

California

Back with 3 modules. Take a look please

main_1

# python 2.7.9

from PyQt4 import QtCore, QtGui
from gui_1 import Ui_Form
from apps_1 import my_app
import sys


if __name__ == "__main__":

    app = QtGui.QApplication(sys.argv)

    #a = my_app.print_situation(Ui_Form)

    gui_master = QtGui.QWidget()
    master = Ui_Form()
    master.setupUi(gui_master)

    master.radioButton.clicked.connect(my_app.print_situation)

    gui_master.show()
    sys.exit(app.exec_())

gui_1

# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-

# Form implementation generated from reading ui file 'gui_2.ui'
#
# Created: Tue Jan 31 18:01:54 2017
#      by: PyQt4 UI code generator 4.11.2
#
# WARNING! All changes made in this file will be lost!

from PyQt4 import QtCore, QtGui

try:
    _fromUtf8 = QtCore.QString.fromUtf8
except AttributeError:
    def _fromUtf8(s):
        return s

try:
    _encoding = QtGui.QApplication.UnicodeUTF8
    def _translate(context, text, disambig):
        return QtGui.QApplication.translate(context, text, disambig, _encoding)
except AttributeError:
    def _translate(context, text, disambig):
        return QtGui.QApplication.translate(context, text, disambig)

class Ui_Form(object):
    def setupUi(self, Form):
        Form.setObjectName(_fromUtf8("Form"))
        Form.resize(300, 150)
        self.radioButton = QtGui.QRadioButton(Form)
        self.radioButton.setGeometry(QtCore.QRect(100, 75, 118, 26))
        self.radioButton.setObjectName(_fromUtf8("radioButton"))

        self.retranslateUi(Form)
        QtCore.QMetaObject.connectSlotsByName(Form)

    def retranslateUi(self, Form):
        Form.setWindowTitle(_translate("Form", "Form", None))
        self.radioButton.setText(_translate("Form", "RadioButton", None))

#    def print_situation(self):
#        if self.radioButton.isChecked():
#            print "Checked"
#        else:
#            print "Unchecked"


if __name__ == "__main__":
    import sys
    app = QtGui.QApplication(sys.argv)
    Form = QtGui.QWidget()
    ui = Ui_Form()
    ui.setupUi(Form)
    Form.show()
    sys.exit(app.exec_())

apps_1

# python 2.7.9
from PyQt4 import QtCore, QtGui
from gui_1 import Ui_Form


class my_app(QtGui.QRadioButton, Ui_Form):
    def __init__(self, parent=None):
        super(my_app, self).__init__(parent)
        self.setupUi(self)
        self.radioButton = QtGui.QRadioButton()

    def print_situation(self):
        if self.radioButton.isChecked():
            print "Checked"
        else:
            print "Unchecked"

error message

Traceback (most recent call last):
  
File "/home/pi/Desktop/Qt4/Project/01/Test_Class_2/main_1.py", line 19, in <module>
    
master.radioButton.clicked.connect(my_app.print_situation)

AttributeError: 
'function' object has no attribute '__pyqtSignature__'

jsulm

@California You should not move anything out of gui.py as it is auto-generated (as @SGaist already said). You should never touch auto-generated stuff.

California

@jsulm copy that. What is max size of the module to work properly?

jsulm

@California There is no such max size. But for your own modules you should try to keep them small (not more than some hundreds of lines if possible), else it will be hard to understand them or change something. How big auto-genereated modules are doesn't matter as you should not change anything there and usually you do not want to read this code.

California

@jsulm In my case gui.py is quite big because all methods related to GUI must be inside GUI class. The problem is, project is not finished yet, so this module will be even bigger after some time.
About diagrams, what tool or library should be used in my project?

jsulm

@California Is it really that important how big this auto-generated gui.py is?
Diagrams? See QtCharts.

California

@jsulm When QTCreator is used, your code is big as my very fast. Tab controll with few pages produce plenty of lines of code ...
Ok, few words about my project.
My project involves RaspberryPi as a Master in RS485 network. This application is like a sort of SCADA for home. On the other side of the network there are slaves responsible for diferent things like temperatures, humidity, consumption of watter, electricity, ...
So Master collets those data, do some calcullations, diagrams, storing data, ... , and most important do some graphic visualisation of everything in network.
At the momment my code covers three slaves, but there are three slaves more to include into aplication. Each slave contains Microchip microcontroller PIC18F458 ...
Slaves are already in function in real situation.