How to detect when QWidget’s layout is fully updated and geometry is ready after dynamic content changes?
-
wrote on 7 Apr 2025, 17:02 last edited by
Hi everyone,
I'm working on a dynamic UI component where I dynamically add child widgets (e.g., QLabel) into a QBoxLayout (such as QVBoxLayout).
Here is my situation:
- Initially, the main QWidget has size (0, 0) because there’s no content yet.
- When I add an item (like a QLabel) to the layout, I expect the widget's size to automatically adjust to fit the content.
- However, immediately after adding the item, the parent widget's geometry and size are still (0, 0), and sizeHint() is (0, 0).
- The geometry (and correct size) updates only later, but there's no clear event to detect exactly when the layout is finished updating.
My need:
- I need to know exactly when the widget has updated its layout and geometry properly so I can calculate a proper display position.
- I also need the geometry ready before starting any QPropertyAnimation on the widget.
- Currently, if I trigger animation or positioning immediately after adding the item, the widget hasn’t resized yet, and it causes incorrect results.
What I’ve tried:
- adjustSize()
- layout()->invalidate()
- QTimer::singleShot(0, ...)
- ...
None of these methods consistently work: the widget’s size is still not reliable right after these calls.
My Question:
👉 How can I reliably detect when a QWidget's layout has fully recalculated, the size and geometry are correct, and the widget is ready for positioning and animation?Any advice, tips, or workaround would be greatly appreciated!
-
Hi everyone,
I'm working on a dynamic UI component where I dynamically add child widgets (e.g., QLabel) into a QBoxLayout (such as QVBoxLayout).
Here is my situation:
- Initially, the main QWidget has size (0, 0) because there’s no content yet.
- When I add an item (like a QLabel) to the layout, I expect the widget's size to automatically adjust to fit the content.
- However, immediately after adding the item, the parent widget's geometry and size are still (0, 0), and sizeHint() is (0, 0).
- The geometry (and correct size) updates only later, but there's no clear event to detect exactly when the layout is finished updating.
My need:
- I need to know exactly when the widget has updated its layout and geometry properly so I can calculate a proper display position.
- I also need the geometry ready before starting any QPropertyAnimation on the widget.
- Currently, if I trigger animation or positioning immediately after adding the item, the widget hasn’t resized yet, and it causes incorrect results.
What I’ve tried:
- adjustSize()
- layout()->invalidate()
- QTimer::singleShot(0, ...)
- ...
None of these methods consistently work: the widget’s size is still not reliable right after these calls.
My Question:
👉 How can I reliably detect when a QWidget's layout has fully recalculated, the size and geometry are correct, and the widget is ready for positioning and animation?Any advice, tips, or workaround would be greatly appreciated!
wrote on 7 Apr 2025, 17:12 last edited by JonB 4 Jul 2025, 17:15@Kevin-Hoang
I don't know the answer to your complicated situation. But I think you might read through- https://stackoverflow.com/questions/17307867/qt-when-is-layout-final
- https://stackoverflow.com/questions/78795785/is-there-a-qt-event-for-when-a-qlayout-has-finished-redoing-geometry
Also, you said
QTimer::singleShot(0, ...)
did not work. What aboutQTimer::singleShot(1000, ...)
, if that does not work don't you have a problem? I am not suggesting this for long term, but as a sanity check.Btw, I'm not sure it's what you want but every widget has a void QWidget::showEvent(QShowEvent *event), you can use that if you have sibclassed, check that for correct size if you want that?
-
Hi everyone,
I'm working on a dynamic UI component where I dynamically add child widgets (e.g., QLabel) into a QBoxLayout (such as QVBoxLayout).
Here is my situation:
- Initially, the main QWidget has size (0, 0) because there’s no content yet.
- When I add an item (like a QLabel) to the layout, I expect the widget's size to automatically adjust to fit the content.
- However, immediately after adding the item, the parent widget's geometry and size are still (0, 0), and sizeHint() is (0, 0).
- The geometry (and correct size) updates only later, but there's no clear event to detect exactly when the layout is finished updating.
My need:
- I need to know exactly when the widget has updated its layout and geometry properly so I can calculate a proper display position.
- I also need the geometry ready before starting any QPropertyAnimation on the widget.
- Currently, if I trigger animation or positioning immediately after adding the item, the widget hasn’t resized yet, and it causes incorrect results.
What I’ve tried:
- adjustSize()
- layout()->invalidate()
- QTimer::singleShot(0, ...)
- ...
None of these methods consistently work: the widget’s size is still not reliable right after these calls.
My Question:
👉 How can I reliably detect when a QWidget's layout has fully recalculated, the size and geometry are correct, and the widget is ready for positioning and animation?Any advice, tips, or workaround would be greatly appreciated!
wrote on 7 Apr 2025, 17:33 last edited by@Kevin-Hoang
if the main widget changes size, resize event may be the better choice. Override the following event in your main widget class.
void resizeEvent(QResizeEvent *event) override; -
Hi,
This will possible once the widget is shown before that it does not have any "physical" presence.
As @JoeCFD wrote, resizeEvent is called when widgets have changed size. -
wrote on 8 Apr 2025, 08:32 last edited by
Thank you all for your support!
Using the resize event works well for my case. It allows me to get the correct geometry as I expected.
There is still a minor issue, but it’s not a big concern for my application.
Thanks again for your helpful suggestions! -
You're welcome !
Since you have it working now, please mark the thread as solved using the "Topic Tools" button or the three dotted menu beside the answer you deem correct so other forum users may know a solution has been found :-) -
5/6