How to implement setHeaderData in a subclass of QAbstractTableModel?

[jdent]

@Christian-Ehrlicher "You already return this." No, I don't see any header!!

"what do I need to call in QTableView to display the header of the model?

Nothing - except you've hidden the header by yourself." What do you mean, I have hidden the header??

[JonB]

@jdent
Your code uses setHeaderData() to explicitly set some header.
From that method you need to save/store that value. Somewhere in your subclass.
Then your header() method needs to retrieve that and return it.
This is what a model like, say, QStandardItemModel will do for you.
When you use your own QAbstractTableModel you have to implement this. In your own member variable structure. For all roles you wish to allow the caller to store data in header.
If you do not need to allow callers to set the header data, e.g. you can calculate what you want, then you don't need a setHeaderData() or storage, you can just write header() to compute and return values.
It's the same principle as what you do with setData() and data() in your subclassed QAbstractTableModel, only done separately for the header data.

[jdent]

QAbstractTableModel has no header() method nor its superclass!!

[Christian Ehrlicher]

@jdent said in How to implement setHeaderData in a subclass of QAbstractTableModel?:

QAbstractTableModel has no header() method nor its superclass!!

It's a typo - it's headerData() as you already found out...

[jdent]

@jdent I am needing to repeat myself because my question goes unanswered. please help!
What is wrong with my headerData()? The problem is I cannot see the header of my QTableView! What am I doing wrong?

[JonB]

@jdent
Start by correcting your code, your last 2 return statements are not acceptable for any role.

	if (orientation == Qt::Horizontal)
	{
		if (role == Qt::DisplayRole)
			return QVariant{ tr("Num %1").arg(section) };
		return QVariant();
	}
	return QVariant();

Then confirm with a breakpoint/debug statement that your headerData() is getting called, and report back.

I assume you have a QHeaderView in your QTableView to see the headers?

[jdent]

ok thanks
I get Qt::Vertical with role 13, 6, 0, 1
then I get Qt::Horizontal with roles 13, 6, 0, 1
I did not have a QHeaderView!! Now I have:

    ui.tableView->setHorizontalHeader(new QHeaderView{ Qt::Horizontal });

and I see a header now!

[jdent]

But now I cannot sort by column!!
and I have

    VectorModel* model = new VectorModel{ std::unique_ptr<AbstractCollection>(new PersistentCollection{ storage(), select(columns(&Claim::id, &Claim::amount))})};
    QSortFilterProxyModel* proxy = new QSortFilterProxyModel{ this };
    proxy->setSourceModel(model);
    ui.tableView->setModel(proxy);
    ui.tableView->setHorizontalHeader(new QHeaderView{ Qt::Horizontal });
    ui.tableView->setSortingEnabled(true);
    ui.tableView->setSelectionMode(QAbstractItemView::SingleSelection);

[jdent]

Anyway I needed to modify sorting: how do I take control of it? For instance if the column has text then alphanumerical sorting must be done and if it is numeric, then the text in the cell must be converted to numeric and the order set numerically! How is this done?

[jdent]

How does one cell's value compare with another? I want to implement intelligent sorting!

[JonB]

@jdent
You should use a QSortFilterProxyModel for displaying your model sorted.

treeView = new QTreeView;
model = new YourModel;
proxyModel = new QSortFilterProxyModel(this);
proxyModel->setSourceModel(model);
treeview->setModel(proxyModel);

Then you do sorting (and optionally filtering too) in the proxy model code.

[jdent]

I have this but when I click the header nothing happens!

[JonB]

@jdent
If you go to the doc page I referenced and read through you will find it describes exactly what you need to do and how it relates to QSortFilterProxyModel or sorting your model.

The idea is to read through the documentation, search for examples and ask questions here when you have researched and have a problem.

[jdent]

Ok, I implemented a subclass of QSortFilterProxyModel in the following :

class SortFilterProxyModel : public QSortFilterProxyModel
{
	Q_OBJECT
public:
	SortFilterProxyModel(QObject* parent = nullptr) : QSortFilterProxyModel(parent) {}

	bool lessThan(const QModelIndex& source_left, const QModelIndex& source_right) const override
	{
		QVariant left_data = sourceModel()->data(source_left);
		QVariant right_data = sourceModel()->data(source_right);

		switch (left_data.userType())
		{
		case QMetaType::QDateTime:
			return left_data.toDateTime() < right_data.toDateTime();
		case QMetaType::Int:
			return left_data.toInt() < right_data.toInt();
		case QMetaType::QString:
			return left_data.toString() < right_data.toString();
		default:
			return QSortFilterProxyModel::lessThan(source_left, source_right);
		}
	}
};

HOWEVER, I click on the header view and nothing happens!! Why?
This is with the subclass and without it!! I would expect resorting to occur in the reverse order when clicking the header but nothing changes!

[jdent]

Sorting is working fine.... its the header view that does not respond to the mouse! What can be going on with the header?

[JonB]

@jdent
Did you look at the docs page? Did you follow the Sorting section code?

Although it does no harm, with what is in your lessThan() at present I don't think you needed to override it. QSortFilterProxyModel::lessThan() already handles the types you have coded for. But if you were to change the behaviour that's where you would do it.

[jdent]

Again, sorting is ok - and you are right not needed to subclass it... The problem I am having is that the QHeaderView does not respond to clicking the mouse!! So, I cannot change the column used to sort at runtime!!

Yet I have:

    ui.tableView->setHorizontalHeader(new QHeaderView{ Qt::Horizontal });
    ui.tableView->setSortingEnabled(true);

And yes I read the Sorting section code!

[JonB]

@jdent
Then the docs say it should be calling sort() in your QSortFilterProxyModel. See if it does, and whether your lessThan() gets called. Is the column's sort indicator responding to your clicks even if sorting is not happening?

[jdent]

At runtime, sort() and lessThan() get called at the beginning (when below code executes) but not when I click the header... also the column's sort indicator is not responding to my clicks and sorting is not happening when I click the header only after the following code executes

When this code executes, sort() is called once and lessThan() is called many times (proportional to number of rows):

ui.tableView->setSortingEnabled(true);

but not anymore afterwards !

[Christian Ehrlicher]

@jdent said in How to implement setHeaderData in a subclass of QAbstractTableModel?:

but not anymore afterwards !

Why should it - once it's sorted why would it need to sort it again?

Please provide a minimal, compilable example of your problem.