A few design questions...

[mzimmers]

But...it's not really a qmake function, is it? Because this special behavior should survive the makefile. Is there a way to do this in the project file?

[giesbert]

but the *.pro files are described in the qmake "documentation":http://doc.qt.nokia.com/latest/qmake-manual.html

"lmgtfy":http://www.lmgtfy.com/?q=qmake+adding+copy

e.g. "this page":http://paulf.free.fr/undocumented_qmake.html

or this on "stackoverflow":http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3984104/qmake-how-to-copy-a-file-to-the-output

[ZapB]

You can do this by defining a custom target in your .pro file. Something like this will do it:

@
myresources.path = $$(MY_INSTALL_ROOT)/resources
myresources.files = myqmlfile.qml

INSTALLS += target myresources
@

The above depends upon the environment variable $MY_INSTALL_ROOT being set. However, this hardcodes the install path.

Instead, it is better to get rid of the $$(MY_INSTALL_ROOT) part of the path and use the DESTDIR feature of make to specify your installation root:

@make DESTDIR=/my/installation/path install@

That separates the install path from your project files.

[mzimmers]

Sorry if I seem a little slow on the uptake here -- I'm coping with multiple unfamiliar concepts. It's been over 20 years since I've used makefiles, and I'm still trying to figure out project files, qmake, QDir and other stuff.

Zap: I like the way your approach looks. I can't find anything on DESTDIR in the docs, though. It's not clear to me how this approach obviates the hardcoding issue; it seems to just postpone it. Obviously I'm not understanding the whole thing.

Thanks.

[goetz]

First: Go with the Resource directory in the application bundle. That's the expected path on OS X. One should not change those things only when it is absolutely necessary.

qmake has support for adding additional files to the bundle:

@
APP_QML_FILES.files = path/to/file1.qml path/to/file2.qml
APP_QML_FILES.path = Contents/Resources
QMAKE_BUNDLE_DATA += APP_QML_FILES
@

This installes the files to YourFancyApplication.app/Contents/Resources - just where it belongs on OS X :)

EDIT: Some more background links in the new "wiki article":http://developer.qt.nokia.com/wiki/Resource_files_in_OS_X_bundle

[mzimmers]

Thanks, Volker. I realize that files should be in the application bundle, and I wasn't suggesting to do it a different way. In the back of my mind, though, I'm wondering what that bundle looks like when copied to a PC. I'm hoping it's a directory.

Do I correctly assume the path/to refers to the path to the source code? Or is that the target?

EDIT:

I tried it two ways:
@APP_QML_FILES.files = ./DemodShaperFilter.qml
APP_QML_FILES.path = Contents/Resources
QMAKE_BUNDLE_DATA += APP_QML_FILES
@

and:
@APP_QML_FILES.files = DemodShaperFilter.qml
APP_QML_FILES.path = Contents/Resources
QMAKE_BUNDLE_DATA += APP_QML_FILES
@

Neither put the file into the Resources folder. It appears that the path is required, which surprises me, because I figured that the .pro file would use its own directory as the default.

So now, the question is: is there some slick way to derive the current path from an environment variable or something, and plug it into the .pro file automatically?

I'm not pursuing this level of automation out of laziness; it's more a matter of having one less thing to remember when stuff gets changed.

Thanks.

[goetz]

[quote author="mzimmers" date="1301602502"]Thanks, Volker. I realize that files should be in the application bundle, and I wasn't suggesting to do it a different way. In the back of my mind, though, I'm wondering what that bundle looks like when copied to a PC. I'm hoping it's a directory.

Do I correctly assume the path/to refers to the path to the source code? Or is that the target?[/quote]

Thats the path of the source. The target path (relative to the bundle) is in the second line.

If you just care about copying the Mac bundle to a windows box, then you're right, it is nothing more than an ordinary directory. On the Mac command line you just "cd" into it, like into every other directory. It's just the Finder that displays the bundle differently and if you call "open myprogram.app" on the command line, it does not open Finder (like for directories) but launches the application.

Regarding deployment on Windows, that's a different beast. You'll probably consider using an installer to put everything in place. You find some hints on windows installers in "this thread":http://developer.qt.nokia.com/forums/viewthread/4498

[mzimmers]

Volker: you posted about the same time I edited my last post, so I'm not sure if you saw my new comments/questions?

[goetz]

The path is relative to the location of your .pro file.

[mzimmers]

Hmm...well, then it should have worked, no?

What totally obvious thing am I overlooking? I could post the entire .pro file if that would help.

[goetz]

Yep, it should have worked. Is the QML file in a subdirectory?

You can try with a test file like this:

@
APP_QML_FILES.files = Makefile
APP_QML_FILES.path = Contents/Resources
QMAKE_BUNDLE_DATA += APP_QML_FILES
@

Not that a Makefile in the Resources is very useful, but it serves well for demonstration purposes :-)

For another test, you could add the absolute path to the QML to APP_QML_FILES.files.

And as a third guess, do you use shadow builds?

[mzimmers]

QML file is in same directory as .pro file.

Regarding adding the absolute path: I'll re-ask my question of whether there's a way to do it symbolically. Otherwise, it doesn't really solve the problem.

Shadow builds: I have a parallel directory to my source, called NNN-build-desktop. That's where all my built files go to live. Is that a shadow build, and if so, is it a bad thing, and if so, how do I do something else?

Thanks.

[goetz]

I don't know about a function that returns the path of the .pro file. As far as I remember this question raised in the forums some time ago.

Shadow builds are not a problem. I just checked with my test project. (EDIT: yep, the parallel directory is a shadow build)

It must be something different, probably a typo or so. You can post the .pro file here and the contents of your directory, so we can check again. If you don't want to expose your data publicly, contact me via private message to negotiate a "secure" channel.

[mzimmers]

No, I think it's safe to share filenames, for now at least.

Here's the .pro file:

@######################################################################

Automatically generated by qmake (2.01a) Mon Mar 28 17:09:16 2011

######################################################################

TEMPLATE = app
TARGET =
DEPENDPATH += . headers src
INCLUDEPATH += . headers

APP_QML_FILES.files = DemodShaperFilter.qml
APP_QML_FILES.path = Contents/Resources
QMAKE_BUNDLE_DATA += APP_QML_FILES

QT += declarative

Input

HEADERS +=
headers/clock.h
headers/DemodShaperFilter.h
headers/globals.h
headers/register_offsets.h
headers/Soc.h
headers/SocReg.h
headers/widget.h
headers/GenericCell.h
SOURCES +=
src/clock.cpp
src/DemodShaperFilter.cpp
src/filestuff.cpp
src/globals.cpp
src/main.cpp
src/Soc.cpp
src/SocReg.cpp
src/widget.cpp
src/GenericCell.cpp

FORMS +=
widget.ui

OTHER_FILES +=
DemodShaperFilter.qml
@

And here's a snapshot of my directory:

!http://www.scopedin.com/images/screen.jpg(directory)!

Thanks...

[mzimmers]

I found the problem: Contents/Resources isn't where the executable is; it's in Contents/MacOS. Works fine now.

That was a nice diversion; now I'll get back to trying to do what Zap mentioned several posts ago. I'll be back with questions about that soon.

[mzimmers]

So, Zap: from reading the section on Q_PROPERTY, it appears that within my top-level class, I replace the variable creation with a Q_PROPERTY. So, instead of:

@int combGainI;@

I'll now have something like:

@ Q_PROPERTY (int combGainI READ readFn WRITE writeFn);
@

Correct so far?

So, since I have to supply a read and write function, am I correct in assuming that this can no longer be an int? I have to make a class for the combGain, and provide gets and sets for it?

Thanks.

[ZapB]

You need the Q_PROPERTY declaration as well as not instead of your normal member variable declaration. This aspect yoru class might look something like this:

@
class MyClass : public QObject
{
Q_OBJECT
Q_PROPERTY( int combGainl READ combGainl WRITE setCombGainl NOTIFY combGainlChanged )

public:
...
void setCombGainl( int combGainl )
{
// Only emit signal if new value is different
if ( m_combGainl == combGainl )
return;
m_combGainl = combGainl;
emit combGainlChanged( m_combGainl );
}

int combGainl() const { return m_combGainl; }

signals:
void combGainlChanged( int );

private:
int m_combGainl;
};
@

The important aspects here are:

You still need to decalre the member as usual

You need to provide a getter method

If you declare the property as writeable (from outside the class) as I have illustrated here, then you must provide a setter function too. It is important (to minimise updates and to break circular dependencies between bound properties) that the setter function only emits the property changed notification signal when it does actually change.

If the variable exposed as a property is purely calculated internally then you do not need to expose it as a writeable property. However, you do need to emit the combGainlChanged( int ) signal when you calculate a new value for it. This is used by the QML framework to update QML items that have properties bound to this property.

I hope all of that makes sense. It will become clear when you get your first C++/QML example working.

As for the property types, you can use any type known to Qt's metatype system (look up Q_DECLARE_METATYPE and qRegisterMetaType in the docs). So all the built in types (int, double, etc. plus all the types handled by QVariant work fine out of the box).

[goetz]

[quote author="mzimmers" date="1301619372"]I found the problem: Contents/Resources isn't where the executable is; it's in Contents/MacOS. Works fine now.

That was a nice diversion; now I'll get back to trying to do what Zap mentioned several posts ago. I'll be back with questions about that soon.[/quote]

But it got copied into Contents/Resources?

A good way would be to put it there and adapt the search paths in your application (wrapped in some #ifdef):

@
#if defined( Q_OS_MACX )
declarativeEngine.addImportPath(qApp->applicationDirPath() + "/../Resources");
#endif
@

(I've not tested it, you might use another path setter/adder for this)

[mzimmers]

Zap: that's a very good explanation. I'm still unclear on the combGainIChanged function, though. Do I actually implement this, or is it part of the BFM of Qt? I ask because I don't see an analog for it in the code we did in the other thread.

It seems that I'm not yet tying data to a display item, too...is that the next step?

EDIT:

Another question: can the combGainI stuff be adapted to be general-purpose, or do I need to replicate this for each variable I wish to display with QML?

[mzimmers]

Hey, Volker:

Just to be sure I was clear: when qmake runs, it puts the executable into Contents/MacOS, not into Contents/Resources. So, I just modified my .pro file accordingly:

@APP_QML_FILES.files = DemodShaperFilter.qml
APP_QML_FILES.path = Contents/MacOS
QMAKE_BUNDLE_DATA += APP_QML_FILES
@

Unless I'm missing something, I don't see a downside to putting the .qml file (and other needed files) into the same directory as the executable...