Problems with websockets

SteMMo

Hi all,
I'm developing a simple Qt app (5.7.1 Windows MinGW) to test a websockets connection to my running websocket server.
I inserted websocket object both in C++ code and QML, pointing of course to same address ( url= 'ws://10.191.40.232:7681') .
Both of them report the 'connected' status but I do not receive any notification on the server: if I send some text by socket.sendTextMessage() fn without errors.

If I connect the server from a browser using Javascript new WebSocket(urlpath, protocol); where:
URL: 'ws://10.191.40.232:7681/' - protocol: 'lws-minimal'
everything is ok.
'protocol' parameter is the only difference I see.
Is there a way to specify the 'protocol' parameter on the QWebSocket constructor?

If I point to 'ws://echo.websocket.org' site I receive the reply.

Any idea?
Regards.

SteMMo

I solved !
The author of the libwebsockets library suggested me to initialize the engine with a default subprotocol if the client did not define it.
And it worked !

Thanks!

Pablo J. Rogina

@SteMMo is it possible that you capture the network traffic between your client(s) and the server? Wireshark is your friend here.

SteMMo

Yes, good idea.
I copied and run the server on my local machine, I opened a console and run tcpdump on port 7681.

sudo tcpdump tcp port 7681 -vvv

In the application I changed the URL to "ws://localhost:7681".
Then I added 4 buttons to the UI interface to open/close/write and get the state of the websocket object.
Results:

Pressed 'open' and the onConnected slot reports 'connected!' debug string
Pressed 'getState' and it reports QAbstractSocket::ConnectedState
Pressed 'Send', the sendTextMessage fn are recalled but nothing else happened
Pressed 'close' and the onDisconnected slot report 'disconnected!' debug string
Pressed 'getState' and it reports QAbstractSocket::UnconnectedState
tcpdump reports NOTHING!

Pablo J. Rogina

@SteMMo so you're saying that you cannot capture any message...
2 things please:

could you try with another different client app connecting to the same local server, and capture traffic? To rule out that you're indeed able to capture traffic
could you show some of your code?

SteMMo

@Pablo-J-Rogina Now I installed Wireshark to sniff on the client side.
Filtering by port number I finally see some data:
i see the GET request and reply with the 'switching protocol'.
The server does not fire the ESTABLISHED phase.
I wrote to the libwebsockets library author to clean the problem.

SteMMo

The author reply me pointing to the subprotocol definition.
But the actual implementation doesn't support the subprotocol, is it?
https://doc.qt.io/qt-5/qwebsocket.html
The request is:

GET / HTTP/1.1
Host: 10.191.40.232:7681
Upgrade: websocket
Connection: Upgrade
Sec-WebSocket-Key: BHWCOoFRwagELAIWRB2iDg==
Sec-WebSocket-Version: 13

fcarney

@SteMMo
Interesting, that page you linked says this:
"QWebSocket currently does not support WebSocket Extensions and WebSocket Subprotocols."

I will have to keep this in mind. We use websockets a lot.

SteMMo

I solved !
The author of the libwebsockets library suggested me to initialize the engine with a default subprotocol if the client did not define it.
And it worked !

Thanks!